Fredo,
I completely agree when referring to such routes as Opal creek (off Eagle) and such - where the beginning of these trails requires a bit more commitment to get to...but this trail in question is different. It is the type to get trashed by mid-night highschool joy rides and such. While there is no question that Don is right about there being more balloon remnants than trash from hikers, that would change on this trail - unless it is maintained on an annual basis. (Even on my recent trips up this trail, I've found recent trash - @ 2 weeks old). Most people don't realize how much clean-up work volunteer crews and forest service crews do to keep our trails clean and preserved.
This trail is highly accessible - and though steep at the start, very easy. (it involves a root ladder) I just suggest caution in promoting un-maintained trails that will be prone to extremely high numbers of hikers - as this one is.) Unless you are willing to go in on a regular basis to maintain it.
My rationale is:
1. Ponytail falls sees extreme numbers all year long.
2. This trail is just the sort to attract beer-toting, bottle leaving evening outings from those who while not conservation-minded, would like to think they are off the beaten path.
3. If this trail does see substantial new traffic, it WILL be trashed. The Forest Service will not be yearly maintaining this route.
4. If you do want to encourage more use on this potentially high-volume trail, I would suggest working with the Forest Service to work out a maintenance plan.
I respect all opinions on this thread, and am happy we're able to address all of our conservation concerns!
-Zach